A Smart TV connects directly to the internet and comes equipped with built-in apps, allowing users to stream content from services like Netflix, Hulu, and YouTube without additional hardware. Unlike traditional TV sets that rely on external devices for content access, smart TVs merge display technology with computing functions, effectively combining the screen and the streamer in one unit.
As streaming platforms continue to pull viewers away from traditional cable, the way people consume content has shifted dramatically. More households now depend on internet-connected TVs to access on-demand shows, movies, and live events—raising a new question for those upgrading their home setup.
If a Smart TV already connects to the internet and offers a suite of built-in streaming apps, do you really need an extra box or streaming device? This question sparks ongoing debate in the age of digital content and smart home tech. Let’s break it down and explore whether that extra hardware still has a place in a modern entertainment system.
Most smart TVs today ship preloaded with a suite of mainstream streaming apps. Expect to find global platforms like Netflix, YouTube, Amazon Prime Video, and often Hulu or Disney+, depending on your region and TV brand. These apps typically sit on the home screen or in an integrated dashboard, ready to launch with minimal setup.
TV manufacturers such as Samsung (Tizen OS), LG (webOS), and Sony (Google TV) curate default packages that align with consumer demand. While the big names are almost always included, niche or region-specific apps might require manual installation from the TV’s native app store.
Each TV manufacturer develops its own proprietary interface. Samsung’s Tizen, LG’s webOS, and Google TV on Sony and TCL models each handle navigation and menu styling differently. These operating systems feature integrated app stores—however, their selection varies widely in depth and diversity.
For example, while Roku TVs offer access to over 5,000 channels in the Roku Channel Store, a Hisense TV running VIDAA OS might give limited options beyond major players. Manufacturers maintain tighter control over what apps are permitted, which restricts the flexibility typically found in third-party streaming devices.
Smart TVs prioritize apps over traditional channel ‘surfing.’ You scroll through thumbnails of streaming services, not numbered networks. This app-first ecosystem replaces the cable guide with content tiles and algorithm-driven recommendations. Some TVs bundle live channel apps—like Samsung TV Plus or LG Channels—which simulate live TV environments but are limited compared to full cable lineups.
The shift to app-based viewing means you choose what to watch, when to watch it. However, users accustomed to browsing channels sequentially may find this transition less intuitive unless integrated with platform-specific live TV options.
Streaming apps won’t work without an internet connection. Period. A smart TV needs a broadband link—either via Wi-Fi or Ethernet—to access any content outside of broadcast TV or hardware inputs like HDMI. For smooth 4K streaming, a minimum speed of 25 Mbps per stream is recommended by services like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video.
When the internet lags or fails, so does your access to apps. Buffering, login issues, or outright loading errors become immediate obstacles. Unlike cable or over-the-air channels, smart TVs rely completely on data transmission for performance.
In the context of home entertainment, a “box” generally refers to an external media streaming device that connects to your television through an HDMI port. These devices override or supplement the built-in capabilities of smart TVs by offering additional apps, smoother interfaces, faster processors, and broader support for streaming services.
Not all streaming solutions come in "box" form. Devices range from compact HDMI sticks that disappear behind the screen to full-featured set-top boxes with powerful processors and internal storage. Some even include dedicated remotes with voice control and shortcut buttons for apps like Netflix or Disney+.
Smart TVs come with many of the same apps found on these boxes, installed right out of the box—Netflix, YouTube, Hulu, and others. However, the experience often differs. Streaming devices launch apps faster, render menus more smoothly, and get more frequent updates than most TV operating systems.
While the apps may be the same in name, the execution varies. A Roku home screen runs cleaner and more fluidly than some budget-brand TV software. Apple TV adds functionality like multi-user profiles and private listening. These devices don’t just replay what your TV offers—they refine it, often dramatically.
Clunky menus and lagging transitions can sour the viewing experience before the content even loads. In head-to-head comparisons, external streaming devices—like the Roku Ultra or Apple TV 4K—consistently outperform built-in Smart TV systems in responsiveness. These devices run on dedicated processors optimized for media delivery, while many TVs cut costs with underpowered hardware.
For example, the Nvidia Shield TV uses the Tegra X1+ processor, delivering near-instant response times. Meanwhile, some TV operating systems like LG’s webOS and Samsung’s Tizen can take several seconds to switch between apps or load settings.
Smart TVs typically offer basic recommendation features, often biased toward their own OEM services. Samsung’s Smart Hub, for instance, frequently promotes Samsung TV Plus content. Streaming devices, particularly Google TV and Roku, aggregate recommendations across platforms using more refined algorithms.
On Google TV, the home screen adapts based on individual watch history, search behavior, and even trending content by region. Devices like Fire TV take this further by integrating Alexa-driven user profiles to produce customized viewing rails, reducing the time spent browsing.
Differing app stores mean differing capabilities. Streaming boxes access broader software ecosystems. Apple TV connects with the full App Store; Roku has one of the most expansive selections of niche and regional apps; Fire TV benefits from Amazon’s ecosystem and Android APK compatibility.
Smart TV built-in platforms often lag in app updates and support. For instance, HBO Max reached LG and Samsung TVs months after debuting on Roku and Fire TV. And when an app becomes outdated or unsupported—common on TV platforms after a few years—there's no workaround without an external device.
TV operating systems are designed as secondary features. Remote controls bundled with Smart TVs are minimal and sometimes frustrating to use. In contrast, remotes from Roku, Apple, and Fire TV include shortcuts, voice search, programmable buttons, and smoother D-pad interfaces.
In contrast, navigating webOS or Tizen often requires multiple steps to reach newer apps or settings. Some manufacturers improve this with software updates, but lag times and inconsistent UI logic tend to persist. Over time, friction accumulates—adding unnecessary steps to what should be a direct experience.
Power up a smart TV, and you'll often wait 15 to 30 seconds before the interface becomes fully usable. Some models, particularly those using proprietary operating systems like LG's webOS or Samsung's Tizen, can feel sluggish during boot-up. In contrast, dedicated streaming devices such as the Roku Ultra or Apple TV 4K power on within a few seconds and are ready to function almost immediately—even from sleep mode.
NVIDIA Shield TV, for instance, uses a fast processor (Tegra X1+), allowing it to remain responsive whether it’s being turned on, woken from idle, or switching between apps. Speed, especially when binge-watching, adds up over time.
Launching Netflix or Disney+ on midrange smart TVs can take up to 5 seconds longer than on external devices. Why? Manufacturers often prioritize hardware cost over performance. A streaming device like the Amazon Fire TV Cube (3rd Gen) includes a hexa-core processor and 2GB of RAM, which handles resource-heavy apps with more fluidity than many smart TVs can achieve.
Performance tests by sites like RTINGS.com consistently show that apps launch faster and multitasking is snappier on new streaming boxes compared to built-in platforms. This speed advantage becomes more noticeable if you regularly switch between multiple apps.
Crashes aren't just annoying—they break immersion. Smart TVs that rely on older or manufacturer-specific platforms are more prone to freezes, unexpected restarts, or app errors. In user experience surveys from Consumer Reports (2023), nearly 25% of smart TV users reported at least one instability issue per month. Roku devices, in contrast, had a reported monthly crash rate of less than 8%.
Apple TV’s tvOS handles memory management efficiently, reducing the likelihood of memory leaks that can cause apps to hang. Google TV on Chromecast has a broader app library but occasionally suffers from lag after prolonged use due to background process overload. However, both still outperform many TV-native operating systems in long-term stability.
Have you ever waited too long for an app to load or crashed mid-episode? Start tracking how often it happens—you might be surprised how much time gets lost.
Firmware updates are the backbone of how well a device adapts to new apps, security protocols, and user needs. Smart TVs, despite their growing sophistication, often lag behind when it comes to consistent and timely updates.
Most smart TV manufacturers release firmware updates irregularly. Depending on the brand, updates may appear once or twice a year — sometimes even less frequently. For example, a 2022 study by Strategy Analytics found that while major brands like Samsung and LG deliver updates in the first few years after purchase, support often tapers off after two or three years. Televisions running proprietary platforms such as Tizen or VIDAA tend to fall behind in long-term support compared to open ecosystems.
Many brands prioritize their latest models, leaving older generation TVs with outdated software. When updates do arrive, they typically contain basic bug fixes or minor app compatibility improvements rather than sweeping feature enhancements.
In contrast, streaming devices like the Apple TV 4K, Roku Streaming Stick, Amazon Fire TV, and Google Chromecast with Google TV operate on well-maintained platforms with larger development teams and broader user bases. These companies push updates more frequently — in some cases, every few weeks — and for longer periods.
This consistency translates into a more secure, more responsive media experience over the lifespan of the device. Feature rollouts often happen platform-wide — for instance, HDR format support, new menu layouts, or expanded voice assistant integration can become available on multiple models at once.
As smart devices become more interconnected, security takes center stage. Streaming boxes follow a more aggressive patch schedule. For example, Google includes security patches in its monthly system updates for Chromecast with Google TV, a cadence reflected by its commitment to Android OS devices. Similarly, Amazon routinely deploys system-level patches to Fire TV OS to counter vulnerabilities.
In contrast, a smart TV that receives a security patch once a year — or skips them altogether — becomes a static device in a rapidly evolving digital environment. Because these TVs are often connected to home networks, any delay in updates can leave them open to vulnerabilities involving app permissions, data exposure, or third-party integrations.
Ask this: in three years, will this interface still be snappy, will new streaming apps still be compatible, and will your data still be protected? If you’re unsure, bolting a dedicated streaming device onto your existing display tips the scale significantly in favor of longevity and reliability.
Smart TVs typically come preloaded with a mix of popular apps—Netflix, YouTube, Prime Video, sometimes Hulu or Disney+. But when it comes to accessing niche or premium content, device compatibility defines your limits. For instance, Apple TV+ isn't available on many older smart TV models. That’s not just about the operating system—it's a deliberate distribution choice. Devices like Apple TV 4K guarantee access, while a built-in LG or Samsung app store may not even list it.
Similarly, HBO Max, Peacock, and Discovery+ launched with staggered availability across smart TV brands. Roku and Amazon Fire TV users received official apps weeks or even months before some TV platforms rolled them out. In fragmented ecosystems, hardware determines permissions.
Certain services bundle access with brand-specific ecosystems. For example, Apple Fitness+ requires an Apple device—not just the app. Want to stream iTunes-purchased movies in full quality? Only the Apple TV box ensures complete compatibility with Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos tracks. Similarly, buying UFC PPVs through ESPN+ works better on supported boxes than on inconsistent smart TV apps.
Each smart TV operates on a closed app environment determined by its manufacturer. That means a Tizen-powered Samsung offers a different library than a Sony running Google TV. Contrast this with platforms like Roku OS, Fire OS, and tvOS, which support a much broader and more rapidly updated range of services. Roku’s Channel Store, for example, holds over 26,000 apps as of 2024. By comparison, Panasonic’s app store clocks in well below 300. If high variety and first-day app launches matter, dedicated streaming hardware outpaces native TV platforms.
Developers often treat smart TVs as afterthoughts. Launching on iOS, Android TV, and Roku takes priority. Exclusivity deals also play a part—Apple isn’t putting FaceTime or Apple Arcade on non-Apple hardware anytime soon. The divide isn't shrinking; it's widening.
Want uninterrupted access to the newest apps, premium services, and live events? Then it’s worth scrutinizing what your smart TV app store doesn’t support—because that will shape your content experience.
Most current-generation smart TVs include basic voice assistant support, typically through pre-installed systems like Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, or proprietary platforms such as Samsung’s Bixby or LG’s ThinQ AI. Depending on the brand and model, functionality ranges from simple voice searches and volume control to more advanced tasks like opening apps or adjusting settings.
However, integration remains uneven. While some models offer far-field microphones for hands-free control, others require remote button activation, creating inconsistency in user experience. Furthermore, Siri support is not widely available outside of Apple-designed products and is generally restricted to AirPlay controls rather than full voice interaction.
Streaming boxes such as Apple TV 4K, Amazon Fire TV Cube, and Google Chromecast with Google TV provide more advanced implementation of voice assistants. These devices embed their ecosystem's assistant at a hardware level: Siri on Apple TV, Alexa on Fire TV, and Google Assistant on Chromecast.
When smart TV systems are not natively integrated into your existing smart home setup, external devices close the gap. If your home relies heavily on Alexa-enabled thermostats, lights, and security devices, linking them through a Fire TV creates fluid voice-controlled interactions. Conversely, a Google Assistant-based setup benefits from Chromecast’s deeper synchronization and unified account access across devices.
Ask yourself: Can your TV dim the living room lights, show who’s at the front door, and change the thermostat via voice? If not, an external streaming box may be the connective tissue that brings your home systems into alignment.
Smart TVs typically come equipped with built-in Wi-Fi, allowing for quick wireless setup. However, Wi-Fi signals can fluctuate—walls, other devices, even your microwave can interfere. That instability results in buffering, lag, and degraded image quality, especially during peak usage hours.
An Ethernet connection, by contrast, offers stable and consistent speeds. When wired directly into the router, your smart TV or streaming box can maintain higher bitrates necessary for 4K UHD or HDR content. For example, Netflix recommends at least 25 Mbps for 4K streaming. Wi-Fi can handle that, but wired Ethernet maintains it more reliably under real-world conditions.
Some external streaming devices specifically include Ethernet ports to overcome wireless limitations. Apple TV 4K (3rd generation) and Roku Ultra integrate Gigabit Ethernet ports for this reason. That feature isn’t arbitrary—it guarantees performance levels that align with advanced video codecs like Dolby Vision or uncompressed surround audio formats.
Bandwidth isn’t just about speed—latency and packet loss significantly affect streaming performance. Streaming boxes with Ethernet capability allow for lower latency and fewer interruptions during live or on-demand playback.
If your household regularly streams in high definition or ultra-high definition while browsing or gaming, upgrading to a faster plan with wired access offloads the pressure from Wi-Fi and improves results across all screens.
Most smart TVs support Wi-Fi by default, but only higher-end models include Ethernet ports. Meanwhile, nearly all premium external streaming boxes offer both options. That distinction matters in homes where router placement limits wireless strength or where interference is unavoidable. Wired streaming boxes solve that problem before it starts.
Your television might have resolved a sharp image back in the day, but age shows in compatibility. TVs manufactured before 2014 frequently lack the processing power and firmware support required to run newer streaming apps like Disney+, HBO Max, or Paramount+. Even if you manage to install an app, the user experience suffers—menus lag, voice controls fail, and streams buffer endlessly.
Other common restrictions include the absence of required DRM (Digital Rights Management) protocols, such as HDCP 2.2. Without it, trying to stream 4K content via services like Netflix won’t work, even if your internet speed supports it. And if you're thinking about casting from your phone, older TVs often don't support Google Cast, AirPlay, or Miracast natively.
Brands like Roku, Amazon, and Google have engineered their streaming boxes and sticks to work seamlessly with outdated technology. Devices such as the Roku Express 4K+ or Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K offer backward compatibility with older HDMI ports and reduce latency, making them effective upgrades for aging televisions lacking integrated smart features.
Plugging a streaming device into one of your TV’s HDMI inputs immediately unlocks access to a modern app store, faster performance, and automatic updates—all handled by the external device, not the TV.
Take a closer look at the HDMI ports on your television. Are they labeled HDMI 1.4 or earlier? These support 1080p at most. Devices requiring HDMI 2.0 or 2.1 for 4K or HDR output won't function at full capacity, and in some cases, won’t display video at all. Compatibility isn’t limited to physical ports; it also hinges on HDCP—a copy protection protocol enforced by content providers.
If your TV doesn't support HDCP 2.2 through at least one port, even a cutting-edge streaming device will be forced to downgrade resolution or deny playback altogether. In these cases, either an HDMI splitter that strips HDCP (often unofficial) or a new display becomes necessary.
New isn’t always better. High-end smart TVs launched within the past year often come with proprietary software ecosystems. Some restrict app installation outside their curated app stores or push specific digital assistants while omitting support for third-party voice devices. If your new TV doesn’t play well with your preferred streaming device ecosystem, it can lead to friction. For example, LG's webOS and Samsung’s Tizen may not offer full support for Google Assistant or Alexa controls.
Assess your TV's current hardware and software capabilities before adding any device. A strategic match between display and streaming hardware ensures uninterrupted performance, maximum content access, and smoother user experiences.
Most smart TVs ship with casting functionality baked into their operating systems. Depending on the brand and OS, this might include Miracast for Android/Windows users or AirPlay for those in the Apple ecosystem. Samsung’s Tizen OS, LG’s webOS, and Android TV each support different versions and levels of device casting. But not all casting is created equal.
Miracast mirrors your phone’s screen wirelessly with minimal setup, but it’s prone to latency issues during fast-motion playback. LG and Sony TVs generally offer decent Miracast performance, while Roku TVs—though based on a different OS—have limited support. AirPlay 2 on compatible TVs offers better stability, though with fewer features than you'd get from native Apple hardware.
While smart TVs come with casting options, dedicated streaming boxes or dongles drastically improve integration. Google Chromecast with Google TV, for instance, doesn’t just replicate your screen. It enables true casting—handing off the video stream from your phone to the device so the TV pulls video directly from the web. This preserves phone battery, reduces lag, and frees up your phone for multitasking.
Amazon Fire TV and Roku devices also support casting, although their compatibility varies depending on the mobile OS. Fire TV plays better with Android devices, while Roku offers its own mobile app to facilitate casting. Both platforms allow the media to be controlled from the phone, not simply mirrored, increasing control without locking the mobile device into streaming mode.
Within the Apple ecosystem, Apple TV sets the standard for mobile integration. iPhones, iPads, and Macs connect instantly via AirPlay 2, offering not just screen mirroring but device-level coordination. You can use an iPhone to calibrate picture settings, enter passwords, or control playback with gesture precision.
Features like HomeKit automation, shared photo displays, and Handoff between devices all operate more smoothly with Apple TV at the center. iOS users also enjoy faster connection times and virtually no input lag during screen mirroring, which makes Apple TV more than a casting tool—it's a centralized extension of the iOS user experience.
For casual users, built-in casting may suffice. But when daily workflows or media habits rely on cast-enabled precision, speed, or ecosystem-specific features, the difference brought by external hardware becomes immediately obvious.
©2025 American TV. All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: All rights reserved. AmericanTV.com is a website for research and comparison as such, falls under "Fair Use". AmericanTV.com does not provide directly phone, TV, and internet service. All trademarks, logos, etc. remain the property of their respective owners and are used by AmericanTV.com only to describe products and services offered by each respective trademark holder. The use of any third party trademarks on this site in no way indicates any relationship between AmericanTV.com and the holders of said trademarks, nor any endorsement of AmericanTV.com by the holders of said trademarks.
We are here 24/7 to answer all of your TV + Internet Questions:
1-855-690-9884
1-855-690-9884